For some Americans entering the Catholic Church, the journey begins with a relationship, whether it’s with a Catholic partner, friend or family member who opens the door.

But for a significant number of people who previously claimed no religious affiliation, the attraction appears to be the appeal of the Church itself, according to a recent report.

A 2026 survey of 2,127 people participating in the Order of Christian Initiation of Adults, or OCIA, across 20 U.S. Catholic dioceses found that nearly 30% of respondents had previously identified as “religiously unaffiliated” — atheist, agnostic, “nothing in particular” or uncertain about their religious affiliation.

Researchers expected relationships with Catholics, particularly romantic relationships, to be an important pathway into the Church for this group. Instead, only about a quarter of previously unaffiliated respondents cited dating or marrying a Catholic as part of their journey.

“What surprised us most was that they weren’t primarily drawn by people. They were drawn by the Church itself,” said Tim Weiske, director of the Department of Parish Vitality and Mission for the Archdiocese of Chicago. “Only one quarter of the ‘nones’ (no religious affiliation) cited dating or marrying a Catholic as part of their journey. Meanwhile, about 6 in 10 pointed to the liturgy and the Church’s centuries-old tradition as sources of interest.”

The survey found that among previously unaffiliated respondents, 76% cited a desire to grow in goodness and virtue, 73% wanted a deeper understanding of truth and 72% sought a greater sense of inner peace.

Those desires often predated any serious encounter with Catholicism.

About half of the unaffiliated respondents said they had already been spiritually hungry and searching. Twenty-one percent said they had explored other world religions, while another 21% said they had experimented with alternative spiritual practices such as crystals, psychics or tarot cards.

“A great deal of searching was already underway by the time ‘nones’ encountered the Catholic Church,” said Pat Brown, strategy and research manager for the Archdiocese of Chicago. “For that group, at least, Catholicism wasn’t the beginning of the search. It was where the search landed.”

A pattern of choosing Catholicism

For sociologist and author Christian Smith, those findings are interesting, but not entirely new.

“There’s always been adults choosing Catholicism,” said Smith, William R. Kenan Jr. Professor of Sociology Emeritus at the University of Notre Dame and former leader of the National Study of Youth and Religion. “It’s just how much people pay attention to it and whether it comes and goes in waves.”

Smith said Americans have long moved between religious traditions, left faith communities, or become more religious later in life. Catholicism, along with traditions such as Anglicanism and Eastern Orthodoxy, has historically attracted people looking for authority, ritual, continuity and answers to larger questions about truth, he added.

What may be different, Smith said, is the cultural environment in which today’s young adults are searching.

Digital life has changed the way people connect, Smith noted. Loneliness, anxiety and uncertainty have become familiar features of life for many young adults. In that setting, a religious tradition can offer community, structure and roots.

“It has roots...that are thousands of years old,” Smith said of Catholicism. “It gives structure and order and direction.”

The researchers heard similar sentiments from OCIA participants.

“Many newcomers aren’t looking for something new,” Weiske said. “They’re looking for something grounded, in a world that changes every day.”

That attraction was particularly evident among Gen Z respondents. They scored slightly higher than older participants on interest in truth, goodness and virtue, liturgy, and the longevity of Church tradition. However, they also reported some of the highest levels of fear about entering parish life, including feeling spiritually unprepared, not knowing anyone, being uncertain whether they would be accepted, or fearing disapproval from others.

“The liturgy is the clearest illustration,” Brown said. “For Gen Zs, it was one of the strongest sources of attraction and one of the most commonly described sources of anxiety.”

A search that extends beyond organized religion

Smith also sees significance in the number of respondents who explored alternative spirituality before Catholicism.

His forthcoming book, “Occulture: The New Face of American Spirituality,” examines the growth of tarot, manifestation, paganism and other metaphysical or alternative practices. Smith argues that American religious life increasingly cannot be understood simply as a choice between organized religion and secularism.

He was not surprised that some spiritual seekers eventually moved from alternative practices toward Catholicism in their search for something more rooted or authoritative.

But Smith cautions against interpreting those individual journeys as evidence of a sweeping return to institutional religion.

The study offers a detailed look at why people already participating in OCIA say they are drawn to Catholicism, but it was not designed to measure the size of a broader religious revival.

The survey was distributed through 20 participating dioceses and completed by 2,127 respondents. Because the dioceses circulated the survey through parish networks, the researchers said they do not know how many people received it and therefore cannot calculate a response rate. They describe the study as an initial effort to better understand the experiences of OCIA participants and acknowledge that the respondents may reflect some degree of self-selection.

The researchers also emphasize that recent growth in OCIA participation should be understood in context. The increases are meaningful compared with recent years, they said, but they remain small relative to the broader decline in religious affiliation and practice.

“Both trends are real,” they said in a written response. “OCIA is growing, and the broader decline is much larger.”

Smith makes a similar distinction. He believes the current interest is real enough to watch, but so far it’s too limited to describe as a broad Gen Z revival.

“There’s something going on,” he said.

Whether that interest in Catholicism becomes something larger remains uncertain. Gen Z could ultimately take a different religious path from millennials, Smith said, or the current interest could fade.

Rather than a sweeping return to traditional religion, Smith said he suspects the future may bring greater religious and spiritual fragmentation, with some traditional communities becoming smaller but more intensely committed.

concept art

Interested in more research relevant to Christian leaders?